C01's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Octopussy]

Great work, but impractical medium for a tattoo.

I think you did a great job, and the shading is top-notch. Especially on the head, the way you created bumps with your shading job works well, and this is a considerable feat for MS paint. However, it seems kinda impractical to use paint to draw a tattoo, considering it probably needs to be more of solid lines for the actual tattoo. Regardless, the reason I'm giving you a 9 is not because of that, but because I feel like additional shading could've been added in certain places, such as the suction cups and the hidden tentacles.

Great job, though!

Hildebrandt responds:

Thanks for the review :)

[Jumping Spiders]

Good Work Here.

For the most part, this is a very nice piece of work. The only complaint I have is the anatomic problems. Especially on the Scarlet Spider, the anatomy is wrong. His legs have muscles going every which way and they don't make sense. Study some anatomy and it'll do you well for future pieces of art.

PickledGear responds:

Tell that to Marvel comic book artists like John Romita Jr. or others, I studied they're style of drawing the human form and just applied it to the drawing.

[Black Hole City]

Interesting piece

The overall concept is very nice, and you drew it well. The coloring job could be a bit better, its very simple, and the smoke or dust doesn't have the texture it should. Also, certain lines in the piece look like there are cracks in the background. Its awkward and somewhat unnecessary. I give it a 9/10 because I think it is very good, but could be fixed in certain areas.

coughing-dog responds:

thanks, the cracks are my lazy attempt at erasing. was a bit of a rush job and my last illustration assignment so I wasnt too fussed. thanks for the critique!